Gary Fuhrman
2014-10-16 13:15:06 UTC
Section 11 of Chapter 3 follows up on the previous section by pointing out
that the "continuous predicate" idea provides an "argument for the unity of
the proposition" which is different from the argument presented earlier, in
3.7. However, although Frederik emphasizes the difference, but concludes
that "both of them are necessary for Peirce's account for the unity of
propositions." To me they seem to be analyses of the same semiotic
phenomenon (the Dicisign) from slightly different angles. But this is a
short section and I won't comment on it further.
gary f.
that the "continuous predicate" idea provides an "argument for the unity of
the proposition" which is different from the argument presented earlier, in
3.7. However, although Frederik emphasizes the difference, but concludes
that "both of them are necessary for Peirce's account for the unity of
propositions." To me they seem to be analyses of the same semiotic
phenomenon (the Dicisign) from slightly different angles. But this is a
short section and I won't comment on it further.
gary f.